[admantis]

I don't understand why you're asking where has unique roleplay gone, but you've emphasized in your entire thread the competence between two servers. You're leaving behind the argument the other servers which want to attract players. Obviously, most people think it's easy and they expect many players by putting a random script and publishing advertisements, like nobody has done it before. They don't know there's much more involved in that, and most of it is related to social aspects, your ability to attract a comunity, much like Calgon expressed.

I would say "who cares just join an already existing server" but I can't because I am making a project myself, because everyone can do it. But if you're going to do it, at least do it right.