Competition -
Nenad - 18.11.2011
deleted...
Re: Competition -
Danny - 18.11.2011
2nd, it got more colors and i like that.
Re: Competition -
Calgon - 18.11.2011
The first signature image has a very poorly sized character - the height/width ratio looks weird.
The second one has a dull and unrealistic fire effect with an unfitting green coloured font.
Re: Competition -
saiberfun - 18.11.2011
let me guess the 2nd is from you...
I actually like the first one although I don't think the character matches the style of the signature
Calgon pretty much said what I wanted to say about the 2nd.
Re: Competition -
Nenad - 18.11.2011
We work in Photoshop for few days now.
This competition is just for fun.
By the way I didn't posted who created which signature because some people know me on this forum and they would rate just for respect or disrespect so it would be unfair
AW: Competition -
Babul - 18.11.2011
1st picture looks like a sepia-effect, the "dot matrix" doesnt disturb the character, it doesnt focus in the exact middle.. but as Calgon pointed out, the characters' pixel aspect ratio seems to be more like 1.3:1, easily noticeable at the hand/head.
2nd pic looks like an overused gamma-correction, nevertheless its more "stressier", the guy holds his gun like "base wiped out, now lets get out of here", nice idea. the flames are are looking clear, no wonder, i bet its a macro picture of some gas burning, but i dont let me get tricked there. it does look good nevertheless.
if both pictures are about getting enhanced, then i vote for 1. its overall design wins imo
Re: Competition -
Vince - 18.11.2011
Second one can be made up in 5 minutes. Find a picture with flames and find a render of the guy on the foreground. Cut the guy out with the magic wand tool, slam it on the background and then add a text with an ugly color to finish it up.
Re: Competition -
Calgon - 18.11.2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nenad
We work in Photoshop for few days now.
This competition is just for fun.
By the way I didn't posted who created which signature because some people know me on this forum and they would rate just for respect or disrespect so it would be unfair
|
Hold shift when scaling the size down of the image next time.
Re: Competition -
Mean - 19.11.2011
Sorry, but the second one sucks. You just took a fire effect pic, cut out the soldier and put the text.
First one is good. Looks nice.
Re: Competition -
lilswizy - 19.11.2011
Looks like the 2nd one is made in paint just 3 layers : render,fire background and ugly text. The 1st one looks way better but as the guys said the render is a bit messed up.