Which one is better ? - Printable Version

Which one is better ? - Printable Version

+- SA-MP Forums Archive (https://sampforum.blast.hk)
+-- Forum: Other (https://sampforum.blast.hk/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Forum: Everything and Nothing (https://sampforum.blast.hk/forumdisplay.php?fid=23)
+--- Thread: Which one is better ? (/showthread.php?tid=289706)

Which one is better ? - park4bmx - 12.10.2011

well i am making a new design for my application
so what you think

Original

In Development

Re : Which one is better ? - Naruto_Emilio - 12.10.2011

Nice, i like both of them, i want to see something with black colour

and not dark blue xD!.

Re: Which one is better ? - Zh3r0 - 12.10.2011

If you intend to make it more styleish, make sure to get rid of the pixels of any other tiny little icon.
Also make sure EVERYTHING is styled, not only that box...

I like the 2nd one better. The first one has some big ass buttons.

Re: Which one is better ? - MusicBeast - 12.10.2011

The second one is way better

Re: Which one is better ? - linuxthefish - 12.10.2011

I like nither!

Re: Which one is better ? - Dripac - 12.10.2011

Second one!

//edit, i don't understand the poll...

"Which one is better?"

And then there is "Very Good" "Bad" etc. -_-

Re: Which one is better ? - davve95 - 12.10.2011

I like the 2:nd awsome job... Looks like a very good program :P

Re: Which one is better ? - park4bmx - 12.10.2011

Quote:

Originally Posted by Naruto_Emilio

Nice, i like both of them, i want to see something with black colour

and not dark blue xD!.

Yep Could do that ;P

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zh3r0

If you intend to make it more styleish, make sure to get rid of the pixels of any other tiny little icon.
Also make sure EVERYTHING is styled, not only that box...

I like the 2nd one better. The first one has some big ass buttons.

yep i agree all the icons will be Re-Designed for better pixels but like it says on the top In Development

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dripac

Second one!

//edit, i don't understand the poll...

"Which one is better?"

And then there is "Very Good" "Bad" etc. -_-

i know it mest up it suppost to be Pic1 & Pic2 but now doesnt let me edit it :X

Re: Which one is better ? - Vince - 12.10.2011

The whole program layout is so messed up to begin with, how do you expect to style it?

Re: Which one is better ? - WoodPecker - 12.10.2011

I like the 2nd, nice job for making an nice design for your program.

Re: Which one is better ? - saiberfun - 12.10.2011

first one,
how should we answer the poll? O_o

Re: Which one is better ? - Kyosaur - 12.10.2011

The second one is better aesthetically. Your application has a lot of redundancy though, which makes it really bloated. Its almost like your application is struggling with an identity crisis. I marked out some of the parts that i found to be redundant / counterintuitive.

Im not even sure why you have that tab widget to be completely honest. Your application has most of its stuff in the main tab! You could honestly remove it and have a config/addon menu option that opens up a dialog instead. I think this would make the application a bit cleaner. You should only use tab widgets if you have an obscene amount of stuff to display in your application (to much to fit in the application, and to much stuff to add to the menu). This is all just my opinion though.

Re: Which one is better ? - Fared - 12.10.2011

2nd one is betta.

Re: Which one is better ? - Kush - 12.10.2011

Frankly, the 'application' looks improper. You attempt to use the same form controls repeatedly whilst knowing they do the same thing (I'm guessing you wanted to take up space?). It looks horrible from my standpoint of view (utterly useless as other "UCPs" or Tools contains a better UI. I apologize if this may sound a bit harsh...

Re: Which one is better ? - toXioneer - 13.10.2011

Im not good in those SA-MP server stuff but im pretty sure that if you use orange color in second pic would be more cool... just my opinion...

Re: Which one is better ? - park4bmx - 13.10.2011

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kyosaur

The second one is better aesthetically. Your application has a lot of redundancy though, which makes it really bloated. Its almost like your application is struggling with an identity crisis. I marked out some of the parts that i found to be redundant / counterintuitive.

well actually i didnt try and use the same buttons and other stuff to fill the empty space
if i show you pictures of different Tabs you will see.

TAB1 (CLOSED)

TAB2

TAB3

TAB4

TAB5

SlideOut Tab

as you can see on the other tabs you dont have the Start/sop/restart functions so i added the SlideOutTab on the right so if your on TAB4 it would be quicker just to open the tab and start it from there.

Re: Which one is better ? - BlazeFury - 13.10.2011

Quote:

Originally Posted by Las Venturas CNR

I like the original. Nice and simple.

Yeap me too! The original one looks better!

Re: Which one is better ? - Kyosaur - 13.10.2011

Quote:

Originally Posted by park4bmx

well actually i didnt try and use the same buttons and other stuff to fill the empty space
if i show you pictures of different Tabs you will see.

TAB1 (CLOSED)

TAB2

TAB3

TAB4

TAB5

SlideOut Tab

It looks a lot better without that side tab! You should think about removing it, or maybe changing the first server control tab a bit. If you keep the sidebar you could remove all the redundant buttons in the first server control tab, and combine the two server control tabs :P. That or you could just fix up the first server control tab a bit (you'll have more space without those buttons) and rename the second server control tab (maybe call it rcon?).

This is looking pretty good man, i like the skin a lot. What is this coded with btw?